Cart
Article
A History of the Structural Theory of Benzene - The Aromatic Sextet Rule and Huckel's Rule
Hi-Res PDFPurchase the full-text
- PDF/HTML,
figures/images,
references and tables,
(where available)
Abstract
This paper shows why the aromatic sextet rule rapidly lost significance in the 1930s and why it has been reevaluated since the 1950s. E. C. Crocker first proposed the rule in 1922, and for several years it was considered one of the most probable hypotheses for benzene. In 1931, E. Hückel applied wave mechanics to the benzene problem and proposed a broader rule than the aromatic sextet rule. The author attributes the rapid decline in the rule of six to four factors: disagreement between R. Robinson and Hückel about the induced polarities of substituted benzenes; C. K. Ingold's criticism of the aromatic sextet rule; W. G. Penney's criticism of Hückel's interpretation; and imperfection in Hückel's own interpretation. But a turning point came with the discovery of aromatic seven-membered ring compounds. The fundamental structure of such compounds was first found by W. v. E. Doering in 1954, when he prepared tropylium cation, verifying Hückel's rule for the first time. This led to reevaluation of the aromatic sextet rule and also Bamberger's axiom.
Keywords (Domain):
History / PhilosophyKeywords (Subject):
Aromatic CompoundsCiting Articles
Citation data is made available by participants in CrossRef's Cited-by Linking service. For a more comprehensive list of citations to this article, users are encouraged to perform a search in SciFinder.
This article has been cited by 6 ACS Journal articles (5 most recent appear below).
Analysis of Hückel’s [4n + 2] Rule through Electronic Delocalization Measures
Ferran Feixas, Eduard Matito, Miquel Solà and Jordi PoaterThe Journal of Physical Chemistry A2008 112 (50), 13231-13238Analysis of Hückel’s [4n + 2] Rule through Electronic Delocalization Measures
Ferran Feixas, Eduard Matito, Miquel Solà and Jordi PoaterThe Journal of Physical Chemistry A2008 112 (50), 13231-13238In the present work, we analyze the π-electronic delocalization in a series of annulenes and their dications and dianions by using electron delocalization indices calculated in the framework of the quantum theory of atoms in molecules. The aim of our ...
σ/π versus π/π Conjugation: DFT Studies on Oligocyclopropenones and Related Systems
Daniel B. Werz and Alexander DüfertOrganic Letters2008 10 (22), 5231-5234σ/π versus π/π Conjugation: DFT Studies on Oligocyclopropenones and Related Systems
Daniel B. Werz and Alexander DüfertOrganic Letters2008 10 (22), 5231-5234DFT studies on oligocyclopropenones and related systems 5(n)−9(n) are reported. A strong σ/π interaction between the π system and the σ framework of the three-membered rings is observed in almost all cases, leading to a perpendicular arrangement of the ...
Numerical Kekulé Structures of Fullerenes and Partitioning of π-Electrons to Pentagonal and Hexagonal Rings
Milan Randić, Harry W. Kroto, and Damir VukičevićJournal of Chemical Information and Modeling2007 47 (3), 897-904Numerical Kekulé Structures of Fullerenes and Partitioning of π-Electrons to Pentagonal and Hexagonal Rings
Milan Randić, Harry W. Kroto, and Damir VukičevićJournal of Chemical Information and Modeling2007 47 (3), 897-904We calculated the partitioning of -electrons within individual pentagonal and hexagonal rings of fullerenes for a collection of fullerenes from C20 to C72 by constructing their Kekul valence structures and averaging the -electron content of individual ...
Quantitative Thermodynamic Descriptions of Aromaticity. A Computational Exercise for the Organic Chemistry Laboratory
Terrence GavinJournal of Chemical Education2005 82 (6), 953Quantitative Thermodynamic Descriptions of Aromaticity. A Computational Exercise for the Organic Chemistry Laboratory
Terrence GavinJournal of Chemical Education2005 82 (6), 953This article describes an exercise that enables students to establish a quantitative scale of aromaticity via computer-driven quantum mechanical calculations using Spartan software. The method utilizes a group of analogous isodesmic reactions from which ...
A Different Story of π-Delocalization
The Distortivity of π-Electrons and Its Chemical ManifestationsSason Shaik, Avital Shurki, David Danovich, and Philippe C. HibertyChemical Reviews2001 101 (5), 1501-1540A Different Story of π-Delocalization
The Distortivity of π-Electrons and Its Chemical ManifestationsSason Shaik, Avital Shurki, David Danovich, and Philippe C. HibertyChemical Reviews2001 101 (5), 1501-1540
Full Text HTMLTools
-
Add to Favorites
-
Download Citation
-
Email a Colleague -
Permalink
Order Reprints
Rights & Permissions
Citation Alerts
History
- Received: August 03, 2009
ACS
Network
Facebook
Tweet This
CiteULike
Newsvine
Digg This
Delicious
