Cart
Article
"It Gets Me to the Product": How Students Propose Organic Mechanisms
Hi-Res PDFPurchase the full-text
- PDF/HTML,
figures/images,
references and tables,
(where available)
Abstract
The ability to use the curved-arrow or electron-pushing formalism is one of the most vital skills in the organic chemist's repertoire. Their introduction to this formalism occurs when they first encounter reaction mechanisms. As they gain experience, the arrow-pushing formalism eventually becomes the primary technique organic chemists use to do retrosynthetic analysis, to predict the chemoselectivity of a reaction, and to create novel methodologies. Because practicing organic chemists use the arrow-pushing formalism in situations that are far removed from the simple contexts in which they are first presented, this study probed how students enrolled in a first-semester, graduate-level organic chemistry course approached the task of writing the mechanisms for two- to four-step reactions that lacked the typical cues that bring common mechanisms to mind. This article focuses on the students' solutions and discusses possible limitations of their strategies.
Keywords (Audience):
Second-Year UndergraduateKeywords (Domain):
Chemical Education ResearchKeywords (Feature):
Chemical Education ResearchKeywords (Pedagogy):
Problem Solving / Decision MakingKeywords (Subject):
Mechanisms of ReactionsCiting Articles
Citation data is made available by participants in CrossRef's Cited-by Linking service. For a more comprehensive list of citations to this article, users are encouraged to perform a search in SciFinder.
This article has been cited by 5 ACS Journal articles (5 most recent appear below).
Egg-Citing! Isolation of Protoporphyrin IX from Brown Eggshells and Its Detection by Optical Spectroscopy and Chemiluminescence
Michelle L. Dean, Tyson A. Miller, and Christian BrücknerJournal of Chemical Education2011 88 (6), 788-792Egg-Citing! Isolation of Protoporphyrin IX from Brown Eggshells and Its Detection by Optical Spectroscopy and Chemiluminescence
Michelle L. Dean, Tyson A. Miller, and Christian BrücknerJournal of Chemical Education2011 88 (6), 788-792A simple and cost-effective laboratory experiment is described that extracts protoporphyrin IX from brown eggshells. The porphyrin is characterized by UV−vis and fluorescence spectroscopy. A chemiluminescence reaction (peroxyoxalate ester fragmentation) ...
New Bouncing Curved Arrow Technique for the Depiction of Organic Mechanisms
Andrei R. Straumanis , Suzanne M. RuderJournal of Chemical Education2009 86 (12), 1389New Bouncing Curved Arrow Technique for the Depiction of Organic Mechanisms
Andrei R. Straumanis , Suzanne M. RuderJournal of Chemical Education2009 86 (12), 1389Many students fail to develop a conceptual understanding of organic chemistry. Evidence suggests this failure goes hand-in-hand with a failure to grasp the techniques, meaning, and usefulness of curved arrow notation. Use of curved arrow notation to ...
Saying What You Mean: Teaching Mechanisms in Organic Chemistry
J. Brent FriesenJournal of Chemical Education2008 85 (11), 1515Saying What You Mean: Teaching Mechanisms in Organic Chemistry
J. Brent FriesenJournal of Chemical Education2008 85 (11), 1515Organic reactions in introductory organic chemistry courses are most commonly taught with a mechanism-based approach to the understanding of molecular reactivity. However, the effectiveness of the popular curved arrow representation to describe reaction ...
Evaluating Mechanisms of Dihydroxylation by Thin-Layer Chromatography. A Microscale Experiment for Organic Chemistry
Benjamin T. Burlingham and Joseph C. RettigJournal of Chemical Education2008 85 (7), 959Evaluating Mechanisms of Dihydroxylation by Thin-Layer Chromatography. A Microscale Experiment for Organic Chemistry
Benjamin T. Burlingham and Joseph C. RettigJournal of Chemical Education2008 85 (7), 959A microscale experiment is presented in which cyclohexene is dihydroxylated under three sets of conditions: epoxidation–hydrolysis, permanganate oxidation, and the Woodward dihydroxylation. The products of the reactions are determined by the use of thin-...
A Simple Assignment That Enhances Students' Ability To Solve Organic Chemistry Synthesis Problems and Understand Mechanisms
Jennifer Teixeira and R. W. HolmanJournal of Chemical Education2008 85 (1), 88A Simple Assignment That Enhances Students' Ability To Solve Organic Chemistry Synthesis Problems and Understand Mechanisms
Jennifer Teixeira and R. W. HolmanJournal of Chemical Education2008 85 (1), 88Organic chemistry students typically struggle with the retrosynthetic approach to solving synthesis problems because most textbooks present the chemistry grouped by "reactions of the functional group". In contrast, the retrosynthetic approach requires the ...
Full Text HTMLTools
-
Add to Favorites
-
Download Citation
-
Email a Colleague -
Permalink
Order Reprints
Rights & Permissions
Citation Alerts
History
- Received: August 03, 2009
ACS
Network
Facebook
Tweet This
CiteULike
Newsvine
Digg This
Delicious
