![]() |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| April 2000 Volume 30, No. 1, 1422. |
Conjugated polymers: New materials for photovoltaics
Polymers can be made to act like semiconductors, giving a new meaning to catching some rays. Gordon G. Wallace Polymeric photovoltaics present the tantalizing possibility of producing coatings that function as sunlight-harvesting paints on roofs or even as an integral part of fabrics to produce electricity from sunlight. MacDiarmid, Shirakawa, and Heeger (1) brought the unique properties of conjugated polymers to the fore in 1977 when they discovered that chemical doping of these materials resulted in increases in electronic conductivity over several orders of magnitude. Since then, electronically conducting materials based on conjugated polymers have been applied in diverse items such as sensors, biomaterials, light-emitting diodes, polymer actuators, and corrosion protection agents. In this article, we review the principles behind generating the photovoltaic effect in conjugated polymers, consider progress to date, and discuss the exciting possibilities that lie before us. Conjugated polymers Although the chemical structures of these materials are represented by alternating single and double bonds, in reality, the electrons that constitute the The behavior of conjugated polymers is dramatically altered with chemical doping. Generally, polymers such as polypyrrole (PPy) are partially oxidized to produce p-doped materials:
p-Doped polymers have wide applicationfor example, electrochromic devices, rechargeable batteries, capacitors, membranes, charge dissipation, and electromagnetic shielding. Less effort has gone into synthesizing and characterizing n-doped materials. Photovoltaic effect in conjugated polymers The characteristics of the photovoltaic effect of a device are shown in Figure 2. The short circuit current (Isc) is the current when the voltage is zero. The open-circuit voltage (Voc) is the voltage when the current is zero. The maximum output of the cell is given by the product IppVpp, where Ipp is the current and Vpp is the voltage at peak power. The values of Ipp and Vpp are obtained from the I vs V curve for the device where the product IV is maximum at a point along the curve. The fill factor (FF) is also important and is defined as The band gaps of most semiconducting materials are typically between 0.1 eV and 2.2 eV, and as such are comparable to the energies of photons whose frequencies lie within (or just outside) the visible spectrum. It is energetically feasible, therefore, that an incident visible-light photon has sufficient energy to excite an electron from the valence band into the conduction band of the material. As a consequence of this single event, two charge carriers are producedan electron in the conduction band and a so-called hole in the valence band. Although the hole that is produced is simply an empty electronic state, which can be occupied by other electrons in the valence band, it behaves as though it is an independent carrier of positive charge. Photovoltaic polymers. Conducting polymers also act as semiconductors, and their electronic properties appear to be analogous to those of inorganic semiconductors. How can this be, when conducting polymers would appear, at first glance, to lack the crystallinity required for the occurrence of energy bands in the solid state? The characteristics of the Putting induced charges to work In conventional semiconductors, the excited electron and the resulting hole migrate freely to opposite electrodes, where they can do useful work in an electrical device (Figure 3). In a conducting polymer, however, the electron and hole that are generated by the incident photon are bound into an exciton (Figure 4). How then, can we obtain any useful work from a conducting polymer if the electron and hole are not separated? It turns out that the bound exciton can be split at interfaces (Figure 5). The simplest interface is created at the junction between the electrode and the conducting polymer. Under open-circuit conditions, holes are collected at the high work function electrode (indium tin oxide, ITO), and electrons are collected at the low work function electrode (aluminum). Indeed, the Voc generated by these devices depends upon the work function difference between the two electrodes. Unfortunately, the exciton-splitting process that occurs at a conducting polymerelectrode interface is not very efficient and is one of the causes of the low quality of early polymer photovoltaics. Another cause of the very low efficiencies of early devices is the effect of impurities, such as oxygen, which act as traps to the migrating excitons. Attempts to improve the efficiency of the exciton-splitting process led to the development of new conducting- polymer species that contained electron-donating and electron-accepting species. By creating interfaces among conducting polymer molecules of differing electron affinities, it is possible to enhance the probability of electron transfer between molecules. This process (photoexcited charge transfer) causes the bound charges to separate, and the junction formed at the donoracceptor interface is analogous to a semiconductor heterojunction. These heterojunctions work very well at separating excitons that arrive at the junction. Unfortunately, the lifetime of excitons is short, and only excitons that are formed within ~10 nm of the junction will ever reach it. This short exciton range clearly limits the efficiency of these photovoltaic devices. In an attempt to develop a more efficient photovoltaic structure, interpenetrating networks of electron-accepting and electron-donating polymers have been produced (3). With these materials, the number of heterojunctions within the polymer blend is greatly increased, and thus the probability that an exciton will encounter a junction and be separated. Research into polymeric photovoltaics is at a very early stage, but the results are encouraging. The best materials produced so far, using a polythiophene molecule as a hole-acceptor (to enhance the absorption of sunlight), have an energy conversion efficiency of 7% when irradiated with green light and about 2% in sunlight (4). Although these materials are currently much less efficient than their silicon counterparts, they do produce much higher open-circuit voltages. By using calcium anodes (which need to be capped to prevent oxidation in the atmosphere) and an ITO cathode, Grandstrom et al. obtained open-circuit voltages >2 V (4). Silicon-based solar devices, on the other hand, have open-circuit voltages that are <1 V. The higher open-circuit voltages produced by the polymer-based devices mean that, compared with silicon cells, fewer polymer-based cells need to be cascaded together to obtain the same net output voltage. This may have significant advantages in certain low-power applications. Device configuration Heterojunction and pn-junction devices can be configured in a similar fashion to Schottky devices, except that the polymer layer now consists of bilayers of a p-type polymer and a n-type polymer (6). In addition, pn junctions can be formed between n-type silicon and p-type conjugated polymers (7). Photoelectrochemical cells have been made from PPy (8) and poly-(3-methylthiophene) (P3MTh) (9). We have used the configuration illustrated in Figure 6 (bottom). In this case, the polymer is coated onto the ITO-coated glass, and solid polymer electrolyte (SPE) is sandwiched between this polymer-coated electrode and a platinized ITO-coated glass counter- electrode. A liquid electrolyte can be used instead of the SPE. The level of oxidation in the inherently conducting polymer has a dramatic effect on the photovoltaic efficiency. Highly oxidized materials are the most conducting, but they are less photoefficient (fewer excitons generated per photon absorbed). Fully reduced materials are highly resistive but the most photo efficient. Progress to date Poly(p-phenylenevinylenes). So far, most success has been achieved by using photovoltaic devices containing PPVs. As early as 1994, Marks and co-workers described the fabrication of PPV-containing photodiodes with a structure similar to Figure 6 (top) (5). The PPV layer was obtained by spin coating the sulfonium salt precursor and then heating the polymer to 250 °C in vacuo. These devices were capable of generating open-circuit voltages of ~1.2 V when aluminum and magnesium electrodes were used or ~1.7 V when calcium electrodes were used. Quantum efficiencies of ~1% were obtained at low-light intensity (0.1 mW/cm2). As discussed earlier, the overall efficiency of photovoltaic devices containing conjugated polymers is determined by the ability to generate excitons from incoming radiation, and then to separate these excitons at appropriate interfaces before they recombine. Given that typical exciton capture zones are limited to 10 nm or less, more efficient structures are needed. This need led several workers to the idea that interpenetrating networks of donor (electron donatinghole accepting) and acceptor (electron acceptinghole donating) polymers should give better results. One approach involves the use of functionalized PPVs (3). The addition of cyano groups to a dialkoxy derivative of PPV (Figure 7, left) forms the CNPPV (Figure 7, right), making it a better electron acceptor. Underivatized PPV is a good hole-transporting material. Using blends of MEHPPV, a soluble PPV derivative, as a hole transporter and CNPPV as an electron transporter results in quantum efficiencies of up to 6%. More recently (4), even higher quantum efficiencies (up to 29%) with overall power conversion of ~2% (using a simulated solar spectrum) were obtained using a modified organic solvent soluble polythiophene (Figure 8, left) as the hole acceptor and a cyano derivative of PPV (MEHCNPPV) (Figure 8, right) as electron acceptor. Perylene is another electron acceptor that increases the quantum efficiency to 6% (10). An alternative approach uses C60 as the electron acceptor (11), giving a quantum efficiency of ~29% and an energy conversion efficiency of 2.9%. Polyanilines. These are perhaps the most versatile of the ICPs with respect to processing options. Schottky barrier devices containing polyanilines have also been produced (12). They can be made using either chemical or electrochemical oxidation according to
The electrochemical method can be used to produce thin films directly on conductive substrates such as ITO. The chemical method can be used to produce a material with the de-doped emeraldine base (EB) form soluble in solvents such as 1-methyl-2-pyrrolidinone (NMP) and some doped forms. The materials are doped with appropriate surfactants such as dodecyl benzenesulfonic acid (DBSA), camphor sulfonic acid (CSA), or p-toluenesulfonic acid (pTS), all of which are soluble in common organic solvents. The dopant has a marked effect. Interestingly, acid doping increased the engineering conversion efficiency from 0.04% (undoped) to 0.57% (poly[acrylic acid]-doped) to 0.88% (pTS-doped). Polyaniline has been widely used in photoelectrochemical cells (1315). Early researchers (13) investigated the photoelectrochemical reduction of chloral (CCl3CHO) to trichloro ethanol (CCl3CH2OH). Shen and Tian used PAn electrodes to induce the photoelectrochemical reduction of peroxidisulfate (14). Photocurrents generated at polyaniline are potential- and electrolyte-dependent (15, 16). Polythiophenes. The photoelectrochemical properties of PThs have also been of interest for some time (7, 1719). Their ability to electrodeposit regular structures with minimal impurities makes it possible to attain high photocurrents (17). The photocurrents that can be attained using PTh-based electrodes have been enhanced by using conjugated linkers to introduce electron acceptors to the PTh chain (18).
The electron-accepting NO2 group facilitates charge separation upon irradiation, resulting in sustained photocurrent. More recently, a photoelectrochemical cell that uses a solid polymer electrolyte based on poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO) was described. Quantum efficiencies of up to 0.6% could be achieved (9). Semenikhin et al. have presented evidence that irradiation causes photoelectrochemical dedoping of poly(3-methylthiophene) or polybithiophene (19), and it is known (see later) that the level of doping influences the magnitude of the photovoltaic effect observed. There is at least one reference to the use of polythiophenes to create pn-junction devices (20); however, no data on efficiency are given. Future developments
Yoshino et al. (21) have considered these steps and suggested that
= where
As Yoshino and co-workers discussed, the most room for improving polymeric photovoltaics lies in improving Thus, there is a need to have high light-collection efficiency, and to have order
These requirements pose some exciting challenges and present some fascinating opportunities. High light-collection efficiency. It is not surprising that there are few reports of attempts to improve the light-collection efficiency of conjugated polymers, given that the fundamental processes in polymer photovoltaic cells are still not well understood. In this regard, particular consideration needs to be given to the possibility that the most appropriate structure for exciton formation may not be the same as that for hole or electron transport. In addition, light absorption affects the polymer structure. For example, it has been reported that illumination of p-doped polythiophenes leads to its reduction or further undoping (19). Two approaches to improving the high light-collection efficiency of polymeric photovoltaic devices could, therefore, be considered. A separate excitonic or dye layer can be used in the device. This approach effectively mimics that taken in liquid-junction photovoltaic cells (22), in which a light-harvesting dye is attached to a thin film of nanocrystalline TiO2. The efficiency of these titania cells is fundamentally affected by how well the dye is bound to the semiconductor. This will also be important for dye-conjugated polymer devices. Yoshino and co-workers (21) have constructed a solid-state photocell with octaethylporphyrin, the light-harvesting or excitonic layer, sandwiched between a phenylene vinylene donor layer and fullerene acceptor layer. Although the photo-current intensity is somewhat enhanced over the cell without porphyrin, a significant improvement is the wider spectrum obtained using conducting electroactive polymers (CEPs). There appear to be two different mechanisms of photo-induced illumination: from the donor side or from the acceptor side. This suggests that both donor-porphyrin and acceptor-porphyrin regions are contributing to charge generation. The light-harvesting dye could be covalently attached to either the donor or acceptor material in the device. A wide variety of light-harvesting functionalities could be attached to the conjugated polymer. Thus, attaching conjugated substituents could enhance the light absorption of the polymer. For example, nitrostyryl side chains have been introduced into polythiophenes and shown to improve photoconductivity (23). We have investigated photocurrent generation with similar styryl polythiophenes having a range of donor and acceptor groups. Some variation in the photocurrent generation was observed for these polymers over a range of poised potentials, although this may have resulted from charge transport effects rather than enhanced exciton formation. Alternatively, known dyes such as porphyrins and bi pyridyl metal complexes have been attached to conjugated polymer precursors (24, 25). There are few reports at this time, however, of the preparation of the functionalized conjugated polymers and their use in photovoltaic devices. Order at the molecular level. The synthetic approach used to produce the conducting polymer of interest determines the degree of order in the resulting material. A number of synthetic routes for polythiophenes have been shown to result in stereoregular polymers. The best known of these are the McCulloch and the Rieke methods using alkylated thiophenes (26). The starting materials are also important. Using oligomers can have a dramatic effect on the polymerization potential required. In fact, it is necessary to use at least monosubstituted thiophenes if the overoxidation of the polymer is to be avoided during the polymerization process. It is known that polymers grown at more extreme potentials are more susceptible to introduction of defects, and that lowering the potential by starting even with bithiophene results in higher yield and greater regularity in the polymer structure (27). Others have shown that the particular electrochemical method used for polymerization is also important. For example, using pulsed potential methods produces more crystalline polymer materials. Substituents attached to the thiophene monomer can lower the oxidation potential (28) and also, as is evidenced in the Reike and McCulloch methods (26), play an important role in inducing order. In addition to the alkylated monomers often used for this purpose, other researchers including Ochiai et al. (29) have attached chiral groups to the thiophene backbone. The choice of dopant incorporated into the CEP during synthesis is another important aspect in inducing order (30). This is most vividly illustrated with the polyanilines. Certain dopants, including CSA and DBSA, induce a structure that is more amenable to secondary doping, changing the polymer conformation from a tight coil to an expanded coil with a concomitant increase in conductivity. MacDiarmid and co-workers (31) introduced the concept of secondary doping and demonstrated the effect using m-cresol. More recently (32), we have shown that more friendly compounds such as thymol or carvacrol can generate the same effects. Certain dopants have even been used to induce chirality in the polyaniline backbone. For example, using one enantiomer of camphor sulfonate is believed to induce helicity with a predominance of one enantiomer in polyaniline (33). Chirality can also be induced in sulfonated water-soluble polyanilines using acidbase pair interactions (34). Creating a highly efficient interpenetrating polymer network containing light-harvesting molecules ensures efficient exciton generation, and the high interfacial nature of the polymer provides a means for separating and transporting the change. The chemical and physical properties of all polymeric components therefore must be such that they are compatible (they do not phase-segregate) to enable formation of these efficient interpenetrating networks. Photovoltaic polymers: promising prospects Acknowledgment References
Gordon G. Wallace is director of the Intelligent Polymer Research Institute (IPRI) at the University of Wollongong (NSW 2522, Australia; 61-2-4221 3127; fax 61-2-4221 3114; gordon_ wallace@uow.edu.au) and chair of the Electrochemistry Division of the Royal Australian Chemical Institute. He pioneered research into the development of intelligent polymer systems, and, with colleagues at IPRI, developed several new sensing, membrane-separations, controlled-release, and biomaterial technologies. He was awarded a QEII Fellowship in 1990, the inaugural Australian Polymer Science and Technology Achievement Award in 1992, and a five-year Australian Research Council Senior Research Fellowship in 1997; and he was the inaugural chair of the Asia Pacific Symposia on Intelligent Materials. He is a prolific author of scientific articles, books, and conference lectures. He received his Ph.D. from Deakin University (Victoria, Australia). Paul C. Dastoor is a lecturer in the department of physics at the University of Newcastle (University Drive, Callaghan, NSW 2308, Australia; 61-2-4921 5426, fax 61-2-4921 6907; phpd@alinga.newcastle.edu.au). He received a B.A. degree in natural sciences from the University of Cambridge and his Ph.D. in surface physics from the University of Cambridge, where he studied the growth of thin films using helium atom scattering. His research interests encompass the growth and properties of thin polymer films, including the development of photovoltaic devices based on conducting polymers. David L. Officer is an associate professor in chemistry at Massey University (IFS-Chemistry, Private Bag 11222, Palmerston North, New Zealand; 64-6-350 4796, fax 64-6-350 5682; d.officer@massey.ac.nz). He obtained his Ph.D. in organic chemistry from Victoria University, Wellington, New Zealand. He joined the staff at Massey University in 1986. He has active research programs in the synthesis and use of porphyrins for photovoltaic and molecular devices and the development of new organic-based intelligent materials using thiophene or pyrrole derivatives. Chee O. Too is a senior fellow and assistant director of the Intelligent Polymer Research Institute (University of Wollongong, NSW 2522, Australia; 61-2-4221 3504, fax 61-2-4221 3114; chee_too@uow.edu.au). He received his Ph.D. in electrochemistry at Imperial College, London. He joined IPRI in 1990. His research interests include electrochemistry, conducting-multifunctional polymers, hydrogels, separation science (including membrane technology), and photovoltaics. |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||