VIEWPOINT
November 1, 1998 / Volume
32
, Issue
2 1
/ pp.
508 A
-
509 A
Copyright © 1998 American Chemical Society
VIEWPOINT
Evolution of scientific knowledge
Ignore departures from the existing framework of beliefs.
Deny that an anomaly exists; blame it on faulty observation or testing error; deride the proponents of the new viewpoint.
Acknowledge the anomaly, but call it "idiopathic."
Try to explain the anomaly with the existing framework, sometimes by making minor adjustments.
Seek alternative viewpoints to contradict or minimize the one proposed.
Recognize the new viewpoint as valid, but within a narrow context relegated to "exceptions."
Accept the new viewpoint as offering some explanatory power, but retain the old viewpoint, too.
Discredit the old viewpoint; deride any attempt to reinstate or rehabilitate it.
Accept the new viewpoint with enthusiasm.
Begin again.
Source
: Reference
2
, adopted from Reference
4
.
Back to article.