Environmental Science & Technology
Skip to Content
Select an ACS Publication

Browse by Issue

Go to issue

Policy News

March 19, 2008

Sacrificing water quality for quantity

The proposed U.S. budget for 2009 would provide money to USGS for determining national water use but cut funding for the agency's water-quality programs.

The western U.S. has faced a full-blown drought for the past 5 years, and last fall's shocking drought in the Southeast U.S. may be a harbinger of future problems. So it's not too surprising that in the proposed budget for fiscal year 2009 (FY '09), the Bush Administration has asked Congress to provide $3 million to the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) to assess water use nationwide. At the same time, however, the administration has proposed slashing funding for USGS's well-established National Water-Quality Assessment (NAWQA) program.

USGS water scientists have tracked water losses during the 5-year drought in the Colorado River basin, evident in drops in the level of Lake Mead, the recreational reservoir and water source created by the Hoover Dam for hydroelectric power.
NASA/RHONDA SAUNDERS
USGS water scientists have tracked water losses during the 5-year drought in the Colorado River basin, evident in drops in the level of Lake Mead, the recreational reservoir and water source created by the Hoover Dam for hydroelectric power. The red band shows water level decreases between 2000 and 2003.

Water experts are concerned about money being taken away from programs that assess water quality, even if it is to focus more on water quantity. "Water availability is, frankly, a growing impending crisis in this country," says George Hallberg of The Cadmus Group, but he adds that both quality and quantity must be considered together. Hallberg notes several concerns for future water resource management that will impact both quality and quantity, including saltwater intrusion in coastal regions, wastewater treatment infrastructure issues, and contamination from surface runoff in urban and rural areas.

To pay for an inventory of water use in the U.S. (the first national assessment since the 1980s), other programs must be cut. NAWQA stands to lose 15% of its current funding, or nearly $10 million. That could lead to the elimination of 70 positions, mainly geochemists, according to USGS.

"Such reductions in NAWQA staff would be a major loss of intellectual capital with many years of experience assessing water quality over broad regions and long periods of time," USGS officials wrote in a synopsis (PDF size: 72 KB) of the cuts. Implications of the cuts also include the loss of testing for drinking-water quality in study areas that supply regions in seven states as well as the loss of data collection on 10 aquifers that feed drinking-water wells across the U.S.

"NAWQA is unique and irreplaceable," says Eileen O'Neill of the Water Environment Federation. "The USGS proposed budget is down $38 million from the 2008 budget," she comments, and the decrease "seems to disproportionately hit the water program," particularly NAWQA. Other USGS programs facing budget cuts include three core areas for the Toxic Substances Hydrology Program: emerging environmental contaminants, pesticides in the environment, and watershed effects from hard-rock mining.

"Water is becoming a key management issue, and one that is going to put limits on social and economic growth," particularly in light of climate change, Hallberg says. New modeling results published online in Water Resources Research estimate a 50% chance that Lake Mead will be completely dry by 2021, as a result of drought, evaporation, expected growth in demand for Colorado River water, and climate change. The researchers calculate that the amount of water lost would be enough to serve 8 million people.

"In the water management arena, we have never had a good database," comments Tracy Mehan, a former U.S. EPA administrator who is now a consultant with the Cadmus Group. "Whether it's ambient water-quality data or a water census, we need data to understand where the water uses are, so we can regulate them or manage" water properly. At odds with this mission, USGS has been losing stream gauges for many years, Mehan points out. Even in states like Michigan, which issued a $45 million state bond to collect 15 years of stream monitoring data, funding is running out.

On a more positive note, the administration's FY '09 budget request adds $5 million for USGS stream gauges. The question now becomes whether Congress will feel enough pressure to set money aside for NAWQA while also funding the much-needed national water census. NAOMI LUBICK

Save/Share This Story
Latest Online News

Science

August 27, 2008
In a recently released document, a federal agency concludes that some pesticides harm Pacific salmon species. Pesticides endanger Pacific salmon

In a recently released document, a federal agency concludes that some pesticides harm Pacific salmon species.


August 20, 2008
The deadly bacteria can linger in biological treatment ponds and elsewhere—but how far can pathogenic strains of legionellae travel in air? New research in <em>ES&T</em> revisits the debate. Tracking airborne Legionella downwind

The deadly bacteria can linger in biological treatment ponds and elsewhere—but how far can pathogenic strains of legionellae travel in air? New research in ES&T revisits the debate.


August 6, 2008
New research shows that conventional drinking-water treatment removes illegal drugs from contaminated water sources. Cocaine from drains in Spain

New research shows that conventional drinking-water treatment removes illegal drugs from contaminated water sources.


August 6, 2008
New flame retardants detected in indoor and outdoor environments

New research suggests that a flame retardant marketed as a replacement for a banned and discontinued PBDE retardant can be found in people’s homes and the outdoor environment.


August 6, 2008
Fertilizer phosphate demands could corrode water safety

Water companies are facing a shortage of phosphate additives that keep the lead out.


August 6, 2008
Protecting farmlands and conserving elephants

A nonprofit environmental group in India takes a new, community-based approach to resolving an ancient conflict between humans and elephants.


August 6, 2008
Comment: Lessons from the flood

Don't build in the floodplain. That's the first lesson I learned (relearned) from the flood of 2008.


More Science News

Technology

August 13, 2008
Sunlight on mirrors

A technology that uses mirrors to concentrate solar power could provide millions of homes with clean energy.


July 30, 2008
Producing usable materials from e-waste

New technologies being developed in China and Eastern Europe may create usable materials from e-waste.


July 23, 2008
The UN reports record-setting growth in green-energy investment last year. Renewable energy spurs “green gold rush”

The UN reports record-setting growth in green-energy investment last year.


July 16, 2008
The top water award from a Swedish nonprofit organization has been bestowed on Orange County’s water district and wastewater utilities. Stockholm Industry Water Award goes to California utilities

The top water award from a Swedish nonprofit organization has been bestowed on Orange County’s water district and wastewater utilities.


July 9, 2008
Faster, cheaper search for antibiotics in the field Faster, cheaper search for antibiotics in the field

A new field kit developed by the U.S. Agricultural Research Service and its partners allows for near real-time water monitoring.


June 18, 2008
Styrofoam: from packaging to picture frames—and beyond Styrofoam: from packaging to picture frames—and beyond

A new technology allows more cost-effective recycling of Styrofoam products.


June 18, 2008
Green chemistry pioneers receive leadership awards Green chemistry pioneers receive leadership awards

The Council of Scientific Society Presidents recognizes Paul Anastas and John Warner for their contribution to the field of green chemistry.


More Technology News

Policy

August 27, 2008
Flammable ice could create a bridge to a sustainable energy future. Gas hydrates on the front burner

Flammable ice could create a bridge to a sustainable energy future.


August 13, 2008
Natural-gas drilling in the northeastern U.S. threatens water quality. What lies beneath

Natural-gas drilling in the northeastern U.S. threatens water quality.


August 13, 2008
A new National Academies report recommends ballast-water management and other measures to bar invasive species from entering the Great Lakes region. Stop the invaders, continue the trade

A new National Academies report recommends ballast-water management and other measures to bar invasive species from entering the Great Lakes region.


August 6, 2008
Study shows that nearly 30% of 2008 model cars have passenger cabin “emissions of low concern”. Study suggests new car interiors emit fewer toxic chemicals

Study shows that nearly 30% of 2008 model cars have passenger cabin “emissions of low concern”.


July 30, 2008
Government pesticide and fertilizer data dropped

USDA has cut the only public source of data on pesticide and fertilizer use on U.S. farms.


July 9, 2008
Sediment laoding, nutrient runoff, and climate change together are threatening the health of sensitive ecosystems like this coral reef. Protecting ecosystems from climate change

A new report by EPA offers suggestions on how to minimize the impacts of climate change on ecosystems.


June 18, 2008
Growing strength—and divide—in climate opinion Growing strength—and divide—in climate opinion

Even as Americans become more willing to act on global warming, opinions are solidifying along party lines.


June 11, 2008
Why is global sanitation so elusive? Why is global sanitation so elusive?

New research shows that factors such as inadequate funding and lack of political commitment pose significant challenges to meeting the world’s sanitation goals.


More Policy News

Business & Education

July 2, 2008
Will the Dragon Stay Green? China After the Beijing Olympics

The country has a chance to continue on its environmental path, beyond the Games and the borders of its capital.


April 23, 2008
The cost of cutting pollution

U.S. manufacturers spent $26 billion on pollution abatement in 2005, according to a government survey.

April 7, 2008
"Virtual water" pioneer wins Stockholm Water Prize

The scientist's work tallied the invisible water used to make food and other products.

March 12, 2008
ES&T Associate Editor Dzombak named to NAE ES&T Associate Editor Dzombak named to NAE

Dzombak is cited for his novel development of models used in evaluating chemical behavior in water-quality engineering and environmental remediation.

January 2, 2008
Green building is escalating

A new report shows a rising trend in the number of eco-friendly buildings in the U.S.

More Business & Education News