Policy News
Panel urges reform of factory farms
A Pew Commission report says health and environmental risks of industrial farms outweigh their cost savings.
Animal farming has become increasingly industrialized during the past several decades, and a new report concludes that this trend has put the environment, human health, and animal welfare at risk. The 2½-year analysis (PDF Size: 6.2 MB) by the Pew Commission on Industrial Farm Animal Production, released April 29, calls for sweeping changes across the U.S. meat- and dairy-production industries that would include banning antibiotics and regulating manure waste much more tightly.
Many of the risks cited in the report stem from the close confinement of large numbers of animals; this promotes the spread of disease and concentrates animal wastes in small areas. The heavy use of antibiotics on feedlots fosters the growth of antibiotic-resistant microbes that cause human illness. High-density animal facilities also produce huge volumes of animal waste containing nutrients and animal hormones that contaminate aquifers and surface waters. The farms degrade air quality by producing high levels of odorous substances as well as toxic gases, particles, and bioaerosols containing pathogens that then infect other animals and humans. Livestock operations also produce 18% of all human-caused greenhouse gas emissions, according to a 2006 UN report cited in the study.
The commission, which is composed of 15 experts in health and agriculture, made strong recommendations despite what Executive Director Robert Martin described in the report's foreword as "some serious obstacles" from the agriculture industry. Among the recommendations were a phaseout, and eventually a ban, on the nontherapeutic use of antibiotics in livestock; a new disease-monitoring program with 48-hour tracing back to infected animals; creation of a new system to deal with animal waste; an end to the most cramped conditions; enforcement of antitrust laws to encourage smaller farming operations; and increased research on animal agriculture practices.
The report was sponsored by the Pew Charitable Trusts and the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health.
