Science News
National Research Council: ozone kills
A review of recent research finds a clear link between smog-forming ozone and mortality.
A new report by the National Research Council finds that short-term exposure to ozone is linked to premature death, even at ozone levels currently found in many areas. The chemical is a key component of smog and causes respiratory and other health problems. The 206-page report, released April 22, recommends that the U.S. EPA consider ozone-related mortality as a factor when setting future ozone standards.
Currently, EPA does not include ozone-related mortality in its cost–benefit calculations for evaluating air-quality regulations. The agency requested the report to help resolve differences in the interpretation of earlier research that links short-term ozone exposure to mortality. Short-term exposure is defined as lasting less than 24 hours.
A committee of health, environmental science, and economics experts examined recent research and found that ozone-related deaths were more common among people with pre-existing health problems. However, deaths were not limited to terminally ill individuals.
The committee also looked for evidence of a threshold concentration below which ozone exposure poses no additional risk of death. Personal thresholds can vary, the experts concluded, but are likely to be lower than current public-health standards.
EPA did not ask the committee to evaluate the agency's use of research in setting new ozone standards in March this year. EPA set both a public-health standard (the ozone level allowed in one place at one time) and a public-welfare standard (a broader protection based on long-term effects of ozone) at the same level, 75 parts per billion (ppb). Because these standards were less stringent than the 60–70 ppb standards recommended by EPA's independent Clean Air Scientific Advisory Committee, the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform in the U.S. House of Representatives launched an investigation into the use of science in setting the new standards.
