Structure–Activity Relationships of GAG Mimetic-Functionalized Mesoporous Silica Nanoparticles and Evaluation of Acyclovir-Loaded Antiviral Nanoparticles with Dual Mechanisms of Action

Mesoporous silica nanoparticles (MSNs) are drug delivery agents that are able to incorporate drugs within their pores. Furthermore, MSNs can be functionalized by attachment of bioactive ligands on their surface to enhance their activity, and nanoparticles modified with glycosaminoglycan (GAG) mimetics inhibit the entry of herpes simplex virus (HSV) into cells. In this study, structure–activity relationships of GAGs attached to MSNs were investigated in relation to HSV-1 and HSV-2, and acyclovir was loaded into the pores of MSNs. The sulfonate group was demonstrated to be essential for antiviral activity, which was enhanced by incorporating a benzene group within the ligand. Loading acyclovir into GAG mimetic-functionalized MSNs reduced the viral infection, resulting in nanoparticles that simultaneously target two distinct viral pathways, namely, inhibition of viral entry and inhibition of DNA replication.


■ INTRODUCTION
Herpes simplex virus (HSV) causes numerous infectious diseases including orolabial herpes and genital herpes. 1 In the clinic, these infections are currently managed symptomatically using guanine analogues such as acyclovir, valaciclovir, and famciclovir, which inhibit viral DNA replication. 1 There have been no further major advances in the pharmacotherapy of HSV infections since the discovery of guanine analogues in the late 1970s. 2,3 Guanine analogues are unable to eradicate viruses from the host following primary infection, with the HSV prevalence remaining high globally. 3 Both HSV-1 and HSV-2 initiate infection of cells by interacting with receptors on the cell surface that mediate viral entry. 4,5 The initial interaction is believed to be due to the electrostatic and hydrophobic interaction of viral glycoprotein (gB or gC) with host cell glycosaminoglycans (GAGs) (e.g., heparan sulfate) composed of negatively charged sulfonate groups linked by hydrophobic moieties. 4−8 Shukla et al. determined that heparan sulfate modified by 3-O-sulfotransferases may also be involved in the subsequent step of viral entry, virus fusion with cell membrane, by binding to HSV-1 gD. 9 HS is therefore also involved in the latter stages of viral entry of HSV, similar to the entry mechanism of human immunodeficiency virus. 10 Molecules that mimic GAGs can inhibit HSV entry into cells; hence, GAG mimetics have the potential to become a new class of antiviral agent for prophylaxis of HSV infections. 11,12 There is great interest in nanoparticles as drug delivery agents because of their many favorable properties including a high surface area-to-volume ratio, which can support high concentrations of bioactive ligands on their surface whilst maintaining a small volume. 13 Using silver, gold, and albumin nanoparticles, the antiviral activity of simple alkyl sulfonate GAG mimetics against HSV-1 was substantially enhanced. 14 −16 In our recent study, an aryl sulfonate GAG mimeticfunctionalized onto mesoporous silica nanoparticles (MSNs) was demonstrated to have low toxicity and inhibit the entry of HSV-1 and HSV-2 into susceptible cells, whereas unfunctionalized MSNs and the GAG mimetic alone were inactive. 17 However, an investigation into the structure−activity relationship (SAR) of functional groups attached to MSNs in the context of anti-HSV activity has not been explored. Hence, in this study, we modified MSNs with various functional groups related to the GAG structure and investigated their SARs against HSV-1 and HSV-2 infection of susceptible cells. MSNs were selected as the drug delivery vehicle because their highly ordered mesoporous interior and large pore volume (0.6−1 cm 3 g −1 ) can accommodate large amounts of loaded drugs, even exceeding 30 wt %. 18 This distinguishing and valuable feature of MSNs, combined with their thermal stability, mechanical resilience, and surface silanol groups that enable facile attachment of organic groups, has enabled the development of highly sophisticated multifunctional drug delivery systems for various diseases. 19,20 In the second part of this study, we explored MSNs loaded with acyclovir and functionalized with a GAG mimetic to simultaneously target two distinct viral pathways, namely, inhibition of viral entry and inhibition of DNA replication ( Figure 1). Silicon-based materials have previously been used to load acyclovir, and their drug release properties were studied. 21,22 However, to the extent of our knowledge, this is the first time that acyclovir has been loaded into GAG mimeticfunctionalized MSNs. Such multifunctional systems that act on more than one viral target may slow down the emergence of drug-resistant viruses. Furthermore, loading acyclovir into MSNs may help to improve its delivery because it suffers from poor oral bioavailability and topical preparations have poor penetration to the dermis, leading to inadequate response in the treatment of orolabial herpes. 23 Indeed, nanoparticles other than MSNs have been used to improve the delivery of acyclovir for the treatment of HSV infections such as orolabial herpes, 23 genital herpes, 24 and ocular keratitis. 25,26 For example, acyclovir-loaded polymeric nanoparticles have demonstrated increased potency compared to the free drug, possibly because of the intracellular uptake of the nanoparticles and subsequent release of the loaded drug. 27 Herein, we report the SARs of GAG mimetic-functionalized MSNs in relation to HSV-1 and HSV-2 infection of susceptible cells. Furthermore, we demonstrate the dual mechanism of action against HSV-1 and HSV-2 by GAG mimetic-functionalized MSNs loaded with acyclovir ( Figure 1).

■ RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Synthesis of MSNs (1). MSNs (1) were synthesized by the base-catalyzed hydrolysis−condensation reaction of tetraethylorthosilicate (TEOS) in ethanol with cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) as the structure-directing agent using a protocol adapted from Kim et al. 28 The nanoparticles (1) were generally well-dispersed (Table S1), providing a greater available surface area for functionalization. As illustrated in Scheme 1, the MSNs (1) were subsequently functionalized with GAG mimetics (3, 5, and 6) or groups that are structurally related to GAG mimetics (4 and 7) to elucidate SARs.
Benzene Sulfonate-Functionalized MSNs (3). Using a method derived from our previous study, 17 MSNs (1) were functionalized with sodium benzene sulfonate at various degrees of functionalization (DFs) to form nanoparticles of 100−150 nm in diameter (MSN-phenyl-SO 3 ) (3) (Figure 2A). This GAG mimetic was selected because it is the simplest form of aromatic sulfonate and MSNs functionalized with this group were previously demonstrated to inhibit the entry of HSV into susceptible cells. 17 The morphology of the nanoparticles was visualized by transmission electron microscopy (TEM), and their size was estimated using dynamic light scattering (DLS). The zeta potentials of all three analogues of MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (3) in aqueous suspension were less than −40 mV, which is likely to confer good colloidal stability because of the interparticle repulsion. 29 The density of the attached sodium benzene sulfonate group was varied by changing the c o n c e n t r a t i o n o f 2 -( 4 -c h l o r o s u l f o n y l p h e n y l )ethyltrimethoxysilane (CSPTMS) during the preparation of

ACS Omega
Article the intermediate sulfonyl chloride (2). Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) was used to measure the change in the weight of a sample of compound as it was heated to 900°C. The silica material undergoes insignificant weight loss with temperatures up to 900°C; hence, the weight loss recorded by TGA was attributed to the loss of the attached functional group and was used to estimate the DF in units of weight %. The results indicated that MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (3) systems with DFs of 11.7, 4.3, and 1.1 w/w % were successfully prepared ( Figure S1A). X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) was used to characterize the attached functional group of MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (3). The low-resolution XPS spectra confirmed the presence of key peaks such as Si, C, S, and Na ( Figure S1B). The high-resolution peak of S 2p was observed at ca. 168 eV for all three analogues of MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (3) (Figure 2B), which signified the presence of the sulfonate form of sulfur. Moreover, 13 C solid-state NMR (SSNMR) of MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (3) (DF 11.7 w/w %) revealed key carbon peaks such as C−Si and aromatic carbons, which confirmed the successful functionalization reaction ( Figure S1C).
MSN-propyl-thiol (4) with a DF of 10.7 w/w % was then oxidized to form MSN-propyl-SO 3 (5) with two different DFs, 2.4 and 5.0 w/w % ( Figure S2A), and the particle size and morphology were unchanged ( Figure 3A(b,c)). This GAG mimetic was selected because the benzene group of MSNphenyl-SO 3 (3) is replaced with an alkyl group, which can therefore be used to compare the impact of aromatic and

ACS Omega
Article hydrophobic interactions on antiviral activity. On the basis of the XPS spectra, the oxidation of thiol (4) to sulfonate (5) led to the shift of the S 2p peak from ca. 163 eV ( Figure 3B(a)) to 168 eV ( Figure 3B(b,c)), which is indicative of the complete conversion of the thiol groups to the sulfonate form. 13 C SSNMR spectra of MSN-propyl-SO 3 (5) with a DF of 5.0 w/w % revealed signals for aliphatic carbons, which is consistent with an aliphatic sulfonate ( Figure S2C). Oxidation decreased the weight % of the functional group from 10.7 to 5.0 and 2.4 w/w % despite the higher molecular weight of the propyl sulfonate group (5), compared to the propyl thiol group (4). This indicates the possible detachment of organic groups from the surface of MSNs during the oxidation process, a phenomenon that was observed previously on oxidized silica surfaces. 30 Zwitterionic Sulfonate-Functionalized MSNs (6). The anionic sulfonate group is believed to be critical for binding to the basic amino acid residues of HSV glycoproteins via electrostatic interactions. To investigate the effect of incorpo-rating a positively charged group alongside a sulfonate moiety, a zwitterionic compound comprising both quaternary ammonium and sulfonate groups was functionalized onto the MSNs. As illustrated in Figure S3A, the MSNs functionalized with the zwitterionic compound (MSN-Zw-SO 3 ) (6) had a size and morphology similar to those of the other functionalized nanoparticles (3−5). Despite the attachment of a zwitterionic functional group with a DF of 9.9 w/w % ( Figure S3B), the zeta potential was negatively charged, possibly because of the contribution of the negatively charged silanol groups ( Figure  S3A). XPS detected the sulfonate group and nitrogen atom ( Figure S3C,D), and the 13 C SSNMR spectrum ( Figure S3E) was consistent with the structure of 6. However, the sodium counterion was not detected in the samples despite the presence of the sulfonate group and stirring the nanoparticles in aqueous NaCl solution (10 w/v %) twice for 2 h. This suggests that the sulfonate group may form a stable intramolecular salt

ACS Omega
Article with the quaternary ammonium group, thus hindering the conversion of the sulfonate to the sodium salt.
Phenyl-Functionalized MSNs (7). A one-step procedure afforded MSNs functionalized with a hydrophobic phenyl group (MSN-phenyl) (7). Similar to the other compounds, MSN-phenyl (7) formed spherical particles of 100−150 nm in diameter, and DLS revealed PDI and zeta potential values similar to those of other types of functionalized particles ( Figure S4A). The negative charge of MSN-phenyl (7) indicates that, similar to MSN-Zw-SO 3 (6), the nanoparticles probably contain a substantial amount of silanol groups. Nonetheless, TGA revealed the successful attachment of the phenyl group to the MSN surface with an approximate weight loss (DF) of 6.8 w/w % ( Figure S4B). Furthermore, XPS showed strong intensity of the carbon peak without the appearance of other elemental peaks ( Figure S4C). The highresolution C 1s spectra revealed a broad peak between 290 and 295 eV corresponding to the aromatic carbons ( Figure S4D). This was confirmed by the 13 C SSNMR spectra which identified aromatic carbons linked to the silica nanoparticles via a Si−C bond ( Figure S4E).
SARs of Functionalized MSNs. The antiviral activity of the functionalized MSNs toward HSV-1 and HSV-2 was evaluated using a plaque reduction assay. Plaques are visible disruptions of the cell monolayer formed following the infection of cells by viruses such as HSV. Hence, the effectiveness of an antiviral agent can be evaluated based on its ability to reduce the formation of plaques, quantified by the percent reduction of the plaque number relative to the untreated control (% viral inhibition). Different concentrations of nanoparticles were used to test the antiviral activity of 3 and 5 against HSV-1 (208 μg/mL nanoparticles) and HSV-2 (52 μg/mL nanoparticles). These concentrations provided strong antiviral activity without causing complete (100%) inhibition. If equal concentrations of nanoparticles were used to evaluate the activity against both HSV-1 and HSV-2, all analogues of MSNphenyl-SO 3 (3) and MSN-propyl-SO 3 (5) may have shown extremely high viral inhibition of HSV-2 or extremely low inhibition of HSV-1, which would make comparisons of different nanoparticles difficult.
To study the antiviral activity, the functionalized nanoparticles were initially incubated with the viral suspension for 1 h before being inoculated to Vero cells. All analogues of MSNphenyl-SO 3 (3) and MSN-propyl-SO 3 (5) displayed antiviral activity against HSV-1 and HSV-2 ( Figure 4A,B). For both HSV-1 and HSV-2, the absolute antiviral response was greater for MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (3) than MSN-propyl-SO 3 (5). Furthermore, when the antiviral activities of MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (3) and MSN-propyl-SO 3 (5) of similar weight % of attached functional group were compared; MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (3) (DF 4.3 w/w %) had a statistically greater antiviral effect against both HSV-1 and HSV-2 compared to MSN-propyl-SO 3 (5) (DF 5.0 w/w %) (p < 0.05; two-tailed paired t-test) (3: 86% HSV-1 inhibition and 92% HSV-2 inhibition and 5: 28% HSV-1 inhibition and 34% HSV-2 inhibition). The two compounds had similar physical properties such as morphology, PDI, and zeta potential; hence, these results indicate that the benzene group of MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (3) enhances the antiviral activity in comparison to the propyl group of MSN-propyl-SO 3 (5). Alternatively, if MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (3) and MSN-propyl-SO 3 (5) were to be compared based on the number of attached functional groups, instead of similar weight % of attached group, the difference in antiviral activity would probably be even greater because benzene sulfonate has a higher molecular weight than propyl sulfonate. The higher antiviral response against HSV observed for MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (7) (DF 6.8 w/w %) (417 μg/mL nanoparticles) and MSN-propyl-thiol (4) (DF 10.7 w/w %) (417 μg/mL nanoparticles) on HSV-1 and HSV-2. The antiviral activity was studied using a plaque reduction assay. Viral inhibition (%) was determined by the percent reduction of plaque numbers compared to the untreated control. The values are the mean ± SD of three independent experiments with duplicate wells per treatment.

ACS Omega
Article increased its binding to the GAG, heparan sulfate, 4 whereas Trybala et al. demonstrated that replacing either of the two hydrophobic amino acids with threonine in the peptide mimicking the binding site of gC substantially reduced the binding to heparan sulfate and infectivity. 7 Dendrimers capped with the more hydrophobic naphthalene sulfonate groups were significantly more potent at inhibiting HSV-2 infection of human embryonic lung cells than dendrimers with phenyl sulfonate groups. 8 Moreover, increasing the degree of sulfation also increased the activity. 8 An apparent concentration−response relationship was established for MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (3), with the maximal effect occurring for nanoparticles at a relatively low DF of 4.3 w/w %. However, increasing the DF of MSN-propyl-SO 3 (5) from 2.4 to 5.0 w/w % did not increase the antiviral effect (p > 0.05; two-tailed t-test), based on the two densities that were studied. When the concentrations of MSN-propyl-SO 3 (5) were doubled from 208 to 416 μg/mL for HSV-1 and from 52 to 104 μg/mL for HSV-2, although a higher antiviral activity was observed, the antiviral response again did not increase with the DF (p > 0.05; two-tailed t-test) ( Figure S5). This suggests that the maximum antiviral activity of MSN-propyl-SO 3 (5) was achieved at a DF equal to or lower than 2.4 w/w %. This value is much lower than the density required to achieve a maximum response with MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (3). However, the absolute response of MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (3) was much greater than that of MSN-propyl-SO 3 (5) despite the response of MSN-propyl-SO 3 (5) reaching a plateau at a lower weight % of functional group than that of MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (3).
Both MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (3) and MSN-propyl-SO 3 (5) displayed an antiviral activity, so to determine the effect of the sulfonate group on the activity, analogues that lacked this group were synthesized. In the case of MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (3), a phenyl analogue (MSN-phenyl 7, DF 6.8 w/w %) was made, and for MSN-propyl-SO 3 (5), a propyl thiol analogue (MSNpropyl-thiol 4, DF 10.7 w/w %) was prepared. In the plaque reduction assay, a higher concentration of these functionalized nanoparticles was used in comparison to previous experiments (417 μg/mL 4 and 7 for both HSV-1 and HSV-2 compared with 208 μg/mL used for 3 and 5 previously) to give the compounds an ample opportunity to exert an antiviral effect. MSN-phenyl (7) displayed a weak antiviral activity toward both virus subtypes, whereas MSN-propyl-thiol (4) did not reduce the formation of plaques ( Figure 4C). Therefore, a sulfonate group (3 and 5), 14−17 but not a thiol group (4), endows the nanoparticles with a strong antiviral activity, and an aryl sulfonate (3) is more active than an alkyl sulfonate (5) ( Figure  4). Negative viral inhibition was observed for MSN-propyl-thiol (4), which means that the cells incubated with the compound had higher plaque numbers than the untreated control. The reason for this observation, which suggests an increase in the efficiency of virus attachment/absorption, is unknown. It may be speculated that MSN-thiol (4) may increase the local concentration of viruses at the cell membrane or alternatively affect the cell or viral membrane to promote fusion.
These results demonstrate the importance of the negatively charged sulfonate group for anti-HSV activity. Next, we investigated whether attaching a zwitterionic functional group, comprised of a cationic quaternary ammonium group and a sulfonate group, onto MSNs confers antiviral activity to MSN-Zw-SO 3 (6). MSN-Zw-SO 3 (6) (DF 9.9 w/w %) was unable to exert antiviral activity on HSV-1 and HSV-2, even at concentrations two-fold greater than the concentrations used to previously study MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (3) and MSN-propyl-SO 3 (5) ( Figure 5). As described above, the sulfonate group of MSN-Zw-SO 3 (6) may form an intramolecular ionic bond with the quaternary ammonium group, thus diminishing the antiviral response.
In accordance with our previous results, 17 unfunctionalized MSNs (1) did not reduce the formation of plaques of both HSV-1 and HSV-2 ( Figure S6). Therefore, the antiviral activity of nanoparticles observed in this study can be attributed to the action of the attached functional groups, with an aryl sulfonate (3) being optimal for antiviral activity amongst the series of tested compounds (3−7).
Our previous study 17 and related studies 14−16 determined that aryl and alkyl sulfonate groups attached to nanoparticles have low toxicity to cells. Forming MSNs is also likely to reduce the toxicity relative to solid silica nanoparticles because of the decreased number of outer surface silanol groups. 17,31 The nanoparticles are unlikely to have interfered with the plaque reduction assays because the concentrations (52−417 μg/mL) and cell incubation time (2 h) were much lower than those in the conditions used to undertake cell toxicity studies (1000 μg/ mL and 48 h). 17 Preparation of GAG Mimetic-Functionalized MSNs Loaded with Acyclovir. Nanoparticles functionalized with GAG mimetics prevent HSV infection by inhibiting viral entry. 14−17 In addition to providing a stable scaffold for surface functionalization, a unique property of MSNs is that their pores can be loaded with large amounts of drug(s), which widens the therapeutic scope of MSNs. 18 In this study, we prepared MSNs functionalized with sodium benzene sulfonate and loaded with acyclovir, which is a first-line drug for HSV infection. This created multifunctional MSNs, which in principle could inhibit HSV infection in two ways: (1) extracellularly, via inhibition of viral entry by the GAG mimetic, and (2) intracellularly, via the inhibition of viral DNA replication by acyclovir (Figure 1).
Functionalizing MSNs with high densities of functional groups can cause narrowing of pore openings and impede drug loading. 32 Hence, MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (3) (DF 6.9 w/w %) ( Figure 6A) was chosen for loading with acyclovir because, according to earlier results, this would afford strong inhibition of viral entry (Figure 4A), whilst a relatively low DF of phenyl-SO 3 (3) (DF 6.9 w/w %) was predicted to be less likely to Figure 5. Antiviral activity of MSN-Zw-SO 3 (6) (DF 9.9 w/w %) against HSV-1 (208 and 417 μg/mL nanoparticles) and HSV-2 (52 and 104 μg/mL nanoparticles) using a plaque reduction assay. Viral inhibition (%) was determined by the percent reduction of plaque numbers compared to the untreated control. The values are the mean ± SD of three independent experiments with duplicate wells per treatment.

ACS Omega
Article impede drug loading. To load acyclovir, MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (3) was first stirred in a concentrated solution of acyclovir in type II pure water for 48 h to allow acyclovir to deposit inside the mesopores of MSN-phenyl-SO 3 . The solvent was then evaporated in vacuo to encourage further deposition of the drug into the mesopores, resulting in the formation of ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 . TGA revealed a high drug loading of 34.0 w/w % ( Figure 6A). Free acyclovir, and acyclovir physically mixed with MSNs, displayed a sharp melting point at ca. 250°C in the DSC curve, which signified the crystalline state of acyclovir ( Figure 6B). Following drug loading to form ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 , the melting point peak disappeared, indicating the transition of acyclovir to the amorphous state and the successful incorporation of the drug within the mesopores. Moreover, XPS revealed that ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 had a sharp nitrogen peak ( Figure S7A), which signified the presence of acyclovir while retaining the sulfonate group ( Figure S7B). As a control, unfunctionalized MSNs (1) were also successfully loaded with acyclovir (ACV-MSN) with a final drug loading value of 30.0 w/w % ( Figure S8). 3 . A drug release experiment was conducted to determine the rate and extent of acyclovir release from the ACV-MSN and ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 ( Figure 7A). This was done to help interpret the antiviral activity of the loaded particles in subsequent plaque reduction assays. In the case of ACV-MSN, the release profile reached a plateau within 10 min, showing the release of ca. 79% of total acyclovir. With no physical barrier to impede drug release, the burst release behavior of acyclovir from ACV-MSN was expected. Meanwhile, the release of acyclovir from ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 was more gradual, reaching a plateau at ca. 30 min, and the extent of acyclovir release was less, with ca. 70 w/w % release after 24 h ( Figure S9). This may be due to the effect of the surface functional groups, which may narrow the pore opening, reducing the rate of drug release, and interact with the drug, preventing complete drug release. Incomplete drug release from MSNs has been reported in the literature, 33−35 and future studies should aim to ensure that release of acyclovir from ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 is more prolonged and complete. Sealing the pores with materials such as polymers or functionalizing inner porous surfaces with small hydrophobic molecules may be useful ways of controlling drug release.

Article
The potential multifunctional antiviral effects of the ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 system were investigated by treating Vero cells with the nanoparticles at two different stages of the viral infectious life cyclepreinfection and postinfection. To evaluate the efficacy of ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 postviral entry, cells were initially infected with HSV-1, and extracellular virions were removed by washing with phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) to ensure that any observed antiviral effect is primarily due to the activity of acyclovir rather than the GAG mimetics. ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 at nanoparticle concentrations of 52 and 104 μg/mL was then incubated with cells for 1 h. Figure 7B illustrates that ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 and free acyclovir at their highest tested concentrations completely inhibited infection when the cells were treated postviral entry. Moreover, MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (3) without loaded acyclovir (MSN-phenyl-SO 3 , DF 6.9 w/w %) at a particle concentration of 208 μg/mL exerted a relatively weak antiviral effect against HSV-1. Therefore, the results indicate that the observed antiviral effect is primarily due to the action of acyclovir and not due to the effect of the GAG mimetic.
On the basis of the drug release study, ca. 65% of acyclovir is released from ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 at pH 7.4, following a 1 h incubation period ( Figure 7A). Therefore, ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 at concentrations of 52 and 104 μg/mL with 34 w/w % drug loading would release ca. 12 and 23 μg/mL acyclovir, respectively, during the postinfection plaque reduction assay discussed above. To determine if the acyclovir released from ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 retains its antiviral potency, comparison was made with free acyclovir at concentrations of ca. 21 and 42 μg/mL. ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 gave an antiviral effect similar to that of a higher equivalent concentration of free acyclovir ( Figure 7B), which indicates that the processes used to prepare ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 do not diminish the antiviral potency of acyclovir. Moreover, the antiviral activity of acyclovir loaded into ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 appears to be greater than that of free acyclovir, possibly because of the improved delivery of acyclovir to infected cells via cellular uptake of nanoparticles as described by Cavalli et al. 27 The effect of the attached GAG mimetic of ACV-MSNphenyl-SO 3 was evaluated to confirm the retention of its antiviral activity, which would endow the antiviral system with dual functionality. Following the incubation of HSV-1 with ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 , including ACV-MSN and free acyclovir as controls, the mixture was inoculated to cells for 1 h. The cells were then washed with PBS to minimize the exposure of the cells to acyclovir during the subsequent incubation period, thus ensuring that the observed antiviral effect is primarily due to the GAG mimetic rather than acyclovir. Although the cells were initially exposed to acyclovir for 1 h, this was before virus infection, which means that sufficient amounts of viral thymidine kinase are unlikely to be present, leading to low concentrations of activated acyclovir. This concept is supported by the lack of antiviral effect of free acyclovir (Figure 8) at concentrations that gave close to 100% antiviral activity in the postinfection assay ( Figure 7B). Furthermore, the ACV-MSN would release ca. 200 μg/mL acyclovir based on the results of the drug release assay (Figure 7A), and it too exhibited no antiviral activity (Figure 8). Importantly, ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 inhibited the viral infection of cells, which is consistent with the inhibition of viral entry. It is postulated that the attached GAG mimetic of ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 bound the majority of virions during the initial incubation period to make the virus ineffective. When inoculated to Vero cells, the virions bound to ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 would be unable to enter and infect cells, leading to minimal plaque growth. Both ACV-MSN and free acyclovir are unable to bind to virions, and hence following inoculation to Vero cells, the unbound HSV-1 is free to interact with cell receptors and infect cells. A similar result was observed in a study by Nazemi et al., where the outer surface of polymersomes was attached with sialic acid to inhibit viral entry of influenza virus and loaded with zanamivir to prevent the release of newly formed viruses from the host cell. 36 Park et al. combined a cationic peptide that is able to inhibit the viral entry of HSV-1 with acyclovir to also target two mechanisms. 37 Such approaches may improve the antiviral effect, and further studies are warranted. Similarly, our proof-ofconcept study demonstrates the successful preparation of drugloaded GAG mimetic-functionalized nanoparticles which are able to target two viral infection pathways. Apart from small differences in viral entry glycoproteins, HSV-1 and HSV-2 are closely related. 38 Therefore, ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 would likely produce a similar result when tested against HSV-2.

■ CONCLUSIONS
This study revealed the important SARs of GAG-mimetic functional groups attached to MSNs in terms of anti-HSV activity. The sulfonate group (3 and 5) was identified as a prerequisite in relation to antiviral activity, with the benzene group (3) enhancing the antiviral response in comparison to an alkyl group (5). MSNs with a benzene surface but lacking the sulfonate group (7) displayed a relatively weak antiviral activity, which highlights the importance of the sulfonate group. This study also demonstrated, for the first time, the inhibition of two different stages of the HSV life cycle by drug-loaded MSNs functionalized with GAG mimetics: inhibition of viral entry and inhibition of viral DNA replication. This proof-of-concept investigation will aid the development of more sophisticated drug delivery systems that are able to incorporate properties such as mucopenetration and/or sustained drug release. A greater antiviral effect of acyclovir was observed when loaded into ACV-MSN-SO 3 compared with free acyclovir; hence, the possibility of intracellular acyclovir release should be investigated in future studies.

■ EXPERIMENTAL SECTION
Materials and Reagents. Hydrogen peroxide 30 w/w % was obtained from Chem-Supply. Ethanol, methanol, and toluene were purchased from Merck. Dry toluene was prepared

ACS Omega
Article by storing toluene over 3 Å molecular sieves overnight. TEOS, CTAB, Pluronic F127, trimethoxyphenylsilane, 3-mercaptopropyltrimethoxysilane, and 1,3-propane sultone were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich. CSPTMS in dichloromethane (50 w/w %) was obtained from Acros Organics. (N,N-Dimethyl-3aminopropyl)trimethoxysilane was obtained from Gelest. PBS tablets purchased from AMRESCO were dissolved in water to obtain PBS pH 7.4 containing 137 mM sodium chloride, 2.7 mM potassium chloride, and 10 mM phosphate buffer. Dulbecco's modified Eagle medium (DMEM) was obtained from Invitrogen and was supplemented with penicillin, Lglutamine, and either 2 or 10 v/v % fetal calf serum (FCS). The HSV-1 used was the HSV-1 H129-GFP strain described in McGovern et al. 39 HSV-2 was a clinical isolate. Acyclovir was purchased from TCI. Unless stated otherwise, the experiments were conducted at room temperature (ca. 23°C). The water used in this study was type II pure water according to ASTM specification D1193-06.
Synthesis of MSNs (1). CTAB (1.0 g) and Pluronic F127 (4.0 g) were stirred in ethanol and NH 4 OH (2.8% NH 3 w/w) (2:5 v/v, 298 mL total) for 1 h to allow complete dissolution. Then, 3.6 g of TEOS was added to the solution, and the reaction mixture was stirred for 60 s and kept under quiescent conditions for 24 h. The particles (1) were collected by centrifugation at a 28 174 relative centrifugal force (rcf) for 15 min and washed twice with type II pure water and finally with ethanol. The particles (1) were dried in an oven overnight at 60°C . Synthesis of MSN-Phenyl-SO 3 (3). MSNs (1) were functionalized with sodium benzene sulfonate to form MSNphenyl-SO 3 (3) using a method based on our previously published procedure. 17 Briefly, the sulfonyl chloride intermediate (2) was formed by stirring MSNs (1) in dry toluene (ca. 1:100 w/v ratio) and CSPTMS under reflux for 18−20 h under an atmosphere of nitrogen gas. Compound 2 was collected by centrifugation at an 18 031 rcf for 10 min and washed sequentially with toluene, ethanol, and acetone. To form sodium benzene sulfonate-functionalized MSNs (3), the sulfonyl chloride intermediate (2) was hydrolyzed by stirring in type II pure water for 24 h, and then the particles were stirred in an aqueous solution of NaCl 10 w/v % for 2 h twice. Excess NaCl was removed by washing the particles in type II pure water twice. The compound was dried in an oven overnight at 60°C. To synthesize batches of 3 with a lower density of benzene sulfonate groups, the DF of 2 was decreased by adding a smaller volume of CSPTMS in the functionalization reaction, which following hydrolysis produced 3 with a lower functionalization density. CSPTMS at volumes of 100, 150, and 250 μL was added to ca. 450, 270, and 270 mg of silica suspended in toluene, respectively, to form three batches of compound 2, which were then hydrolyzed to afford compound 3 with three different DFs.
Synthesis of MSN-Propyl-Thiol (4) and MSN-Propyl-SO 3 (5). To form the thiol intermediate, 3-mercaptopropyltrimethoxysilane was added dropwise to a suspension of MSNs (1) in methanol at 60°C and stirred overnight. The particles were collected by centrifugation at a 32 055 rcf for 15 min and washed twice with type II pure water. The thiol-functionalized MSNs (MSN-propyl-thiol) (4) were dried in an oven overnight at 60°C.
To form propyl sulfonate-functionalized MSNs (MSNpropyl-SO 3 ) (5), MSN-propyl-thiol (4) was oxidized by stirring in aqueous H 2 O 2 30 w/w % for 24 h. The particles were collected by centrifugation at an 18 031 rcf for 15 min and washed twice with type II pure water. The particles were stirred in an aqueous solution of NaCl 10 w/v % for 2 h twice. Excess NaCl was removed by washing the particles in type II pure water twice. The compound was dried in an oven overnight at 60°C.
To functionalize zwitterionic silane onto the surface of silica nanoparticles (MSN-Zw-SO 3 ) (6), a protocol adapted from Estephan et al. was used. 40 MSNs (1) (140 mg) were dispersed in 30 mL of type II pure water, and an aqueous solution of 3-(dimethyl(3-(trimethoxysilyl)propyl)-ammonio)propane-1-sulfonate (0.5 mL, ca. 160 mg/mL in type II pure water) was added. The mixture was stirred at 80°C for 24 h. The particles were collected by centrifugation (32 055 rcf, 15 min) and washed twice with type II pure water. The particles were then stirred in aqueous NaCl solution (10 w/v %) twice for 2 h. The compound (6) was finally washed with type II pure water and dried overnight at 60°C.
Synthesis of MSN-Phenyl (7). Trimethoxyphenylsilane (1.2 mL) was added to a stirred suspension of MSNs (1) (170 mg) in 30 mL of dry toluene. The reaction proceeded under reflux for 20 h under an atmosphere of nitrogen gas. The particles were collected by centrifugation at an 18 031 rcf for 15 min and washed sequentially with toluene, ethanol, and acetone. The compound (MSN-phenyl) (7) was dried in an oven overnight at 60°C.
Preparation of Acyclovir-Loaded MSNs. MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (3) or unfunctionalized MSNs (1) (20 mg) were dispersed in 1 mL of ethanol using a bath sonicator for 10 min and then added to an aqueous solution of acyclovir (50 mg of acyclovir in 6 mL of type I pure water) and stirred at 200 rpm for 48 h. The solvent was removed in vacuo using a rotary evaporator, and the dried powder was washed six times with 10 mL of type II pure water to remove excess acyclovir adsorbed on the surface of drug-loaded nanoparticles. The compounds (ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 and ACV-MSN) were dried in an oven overnight at 60°C.
Characterization. The hydrodynamic diameter, PDI, and zeta potential of the nanoparticle suspensions in type II pure water were measured using a Malvern Nano ZS Zetasizer. The size and morphology of the nanoparticles were determined based on TEM images using a JEOL 1010 instrument operated at 100 kV. The TEM samples were prepared on 200-mesh copper-coated grids.
A Mettler Toledo TGA/DSC 2 STAR system was used to obtain TGA data on the nanoparticles which were weighed into aluminum oxide crucibles. The weight loss of samples was recorded as the temperature was increased from 50−900°C at a heating rate of 5°C/min. XPS was conducted using a Kratos Axis ULTRA X-ray photoelectron spectrometer. 13 C SSNMR spectra were obtained using a Bruker AVANCE III spectrometer operated at 300 MHz.

ACS Omega
Article Drug Release. The release of acyclovir from acyclovirloaded MSN-phenyl-SO 3 was investigated using a pH 7.4 phosphate buffer. ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 or ACV-MSN was added to 50 mL of pH 7.4 buffer and stirred at 100 rpm at 37°C under sink conditions. Samples (1.5 mL) were withdrawn at predetermined time intervals (0, 10, 20, 30 min, 1, and 2 h) and immediately replaced with an equal volume of fresh buffer solution to maintain a constant volume. The withdrawn samples were centrifuged (12 000 rcf, 4 min), and the concentration of acyclovir was determined using UV−visible spectrophotometry at a λ max value of 253 nm by reference to a calibration curve (R 2 values > 0.99).
SAR Studies. Vero cells were grown overnight in 24-well plates at a seeding density of 1.2 × 10 5 cells/well. Nanoparticles suspended in PBS (250 μL) were mixed with HSV-1 (ca. 49 plaque-forming unitspfu) or HSV-2 (ca. 38 pfu) diluted with DMEM 2% FCS (50 μL) and incubated for 1 h. The suspension was inoculated to Vero cells, incubated for 1 h at 37°C to enable virus binding/entry, and the suspension was then aspirated and overlayed with 0.6% carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC) in DMEM 2% FCS at 1 mL/well. After incubating the plates for 3 days, the cells were fixed with formaldehyde in PBS (0.4 w/v %) and stained with toluidine blue in water (0.1 w/v %), and the plaques were counted under a microscope. In our previous study, 17 MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (3) was determined to have only minor effect on the viability of Vero cells following 48 h of incubation at concentrations up to 1000 μg/mL. Therefore, cytotoxicity was not studied in this project because, in the SAR studies, relatively low concentrations of nanoparticles were used with relatively short exposure times.
Acyclovir Study. PreinfectionVero cells were grown overnight in 24-well plates at a seeding density of 1.2 × 10 5 cells/well. ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (833 μg/mL), ACV-MSN (833 μg/mL), and free acyclovir (42 μg/mL) suspended in PBS were mixed with HSV-1 (ca. 35 pfu) diluted with DMEM 2% FCS and incubated for 1 h. At the tested concentration, ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 would have released ca. 185 μg/mL and ACV-MSN released ca. 200 μg/mL of acyclovir after 1 h based on the drug release experiment. The suspension was inoculated to Vero cells for 1 h at 37°C. The cells were washed twice with PBS to exclude the effects of acyclovir released into the extracellular environment. The suspension was then aspirated and overlayed with 0.6% CMC in DMEM 2% FCS at 1 mL/well. After incubating the plates for 3 days, the cells were fixed, stained, and counted as described above.
PostinfectionTo investigate the effect of the loaded acyclovir of ACV-MSN-phenyl-SO 3 , Vero cells (1.2 × 10 5 cells/well) grown in 24-well plates were infected with HSV-1 (ca. 71 pfu/well), for 2 h at 37°C with 5% CO 2 . The extracellular viruses were removed by washing the wells with PBS twice. The cells were then inoculated with ACV-MSNphenyl-SO 3 (52 and 104 μg/mL nanoparticle equivalent to approximately 12 and 23 μg/mL acyclovir, respectively, following 1 h of incubation), acyclovir (21 and 42 μg/mL), or MSN-phenyl-SO 3 (3) with a DF of 6 w/w % (208 μg/mL) dispersed/dissolved in PBS for 1 h at 37°C with 5% CO 2 . The suspension was aspirated and overlayed with 0.6% CMC in DMEM 2% FCS at 1 mL/well. After incubating the plates for 3 days, the cells were fixed, stained, and counted as described above.